Is Premium Economy Worth the Upgrade? A Corporate Traveler's Perspective With 11 Airlines

The corporate travel landscape is experiencing a shift. As airfares continue to rise across the board, companies are looking for ways to optimize travel budgets without sacrificing employee well-being. This is where premium economy airfares have emerged as a compelling option. Offering a middle ground between cramped economy seating and luxurious business class, premium economy presents a unique value proposition for business travelers.

Demystifying Premium Economy Airfare

So, what exactly is the premium economy? It's a distinct cabin class situated between economy and business class. Airlines have tailored this class to cater to travelers seeking an enhanced travel experience compared to standard economy. This translates to increased legroom, wider seats, improved amenities, and often, more personalized service.

A Breakdown of Airfare Types

To understand the premium economy's positioning, let's delve into the different airfare types -

Economy Class - The most affordable option, offering basic amenities and limited legroom. While budget-friendly, long journeys can be uncomfortable.

Premium Economy - As mentioned earlier, it bridges the gap between economy and business class, providing enhanced comfort and amenities at a premium over the economy.

Business Class - Offers a luxurious travel experience with spacious lie-flat seats, premium in-flight meals, and priority check-in and boarding. However, it comes with a significantly higher price tag.

First Class - The epitome of air travel luxury, featuring private suites, gourmet dining, and unparalleled service. It's reserved primarily for long-haul flights and caters to a very specific clientele.

Premium Economy vs. Economy and Business Class: A Comparative View

Let's dissect the key differences between the premium economy and its neighboring classes -

Economy vs. Premium Economy - Compared to the economy, the premium economy offers significant benefits. Passengers can expect an average of 6-8 inches extra legroom, wider seats for improved comfort, and often, enhanced amenities like upgraded entertainment systems, amenity kits, and priority boarding.

Premium Economy vs. Business Class - While premium economy offers more space and comfort than economy, it doesn't match the luxurious experience of business class. Business class boasts lie-flat seats, extensive dining options, and personalized service, making it ideal for long-haul flights where maximum rest and comfort are paramount.

The Corporate Traveler's Advantage

Corporations can leverage the premium economy for several reasons -

Improved Employee Well-being - Extended legroom and better seating contribute to a more comfortable travel experience, reducing fatigue and allowing employees to arrive at their destination refreshed and ready to work.

Enhanced Productivity - Increased comfort translates to improved productivity during the journey. Employees can utilize the additional legroom to work comfortably on laptops or tablets.

Cost-Effectiveness - Compared to business class, premium economy offers significant cost savings, allowing companies to maintain employee comfort without exceeding travel budgets.

Choosing the Right Premium Economy Experience

When selecting a premium economy option, consider these factors -

Seat Pitch & Width - Look for airlines with ample legroom and wider seat layouts for better comfort. Statistics indicate an average premium economy seat pitch of 38 inches compared to 31 inches in economy.

Amenities - Evaluate the amenities offered, including in-flight entertainment systems, meal service quality, and amenity kits.

Airline Reputation - Opt for airlines known for their service quality and passenger comfort in premium economy.

Airlines with Economy Cabins Worth the Splurge

Several airlines boast exceptional premium economy experiences:

Singapore Airlines

Renowned for its industry-leading service standards and spacious seats with generous legroom. Passengers can expect a top-notch entertainment system featuring the latest movies and TV shows, along with complimentary amenity kits and a selection of wines and champagnes.

Emirates

Offers comfortable seats with ample legroom and a generous recline angle. Passengers enjoy an extensive selection of entertainment options, regionally inspired cuisine with a focus on fresh ingredients, and complimentary amenities like noise-canceling headphones and eye masks.

Qantas

Features spacious seats with comfortable headrests and adjustable leg rests. Passengers benefit from complimentary noise-canceling headphones, an extensive in-flight entertainment library, and a curated selection of Australian wines and beverages.

Virgin Atlantic

Provides spacious leather seats with ample legroom and mood lighting that adjusts throughout the flight. Passengers have access to an on-demand entertainment system with a wide variety of content, along with complimentary amenity kits and a selection of premium beverages.

Cathay Pacific

Offers comfortable ergonomic seats with ample legroom and adjustable headrests. Passengers receive noise-canceling headphones and amenity kits and can enjoy an extensive entertainment library featuring the latest movies, TV shows, and music. Cathay Pacific is known for its attentive service and focus on passenger comfort.

KLM Royal Dutch Airlines

Features spacious seats with adjustable headrests and leg rests, offering a comfortable experience for long journeys. Passengers can enjoy a personalized entertainment system with a wide selection of movies and TV shows. KLM also focuses on Dutch cuisine, offering a taste of the Netherlands on board.

Lufthansa

Provides comfortable leather seats with adjustable headrests and in-seat power outlets, allowing passengers to stay charged throughout the flight. Passengers have access to a diverse entertainment selection and complimentary amenity kits. Lufthansa is known for its German efficiency and focus on punctuality.

British Airways

Offers spacious seats with adjustable headrests and in-seat power outlets, allowing passengers to stay connected and productive during the flight. Passengers can personalize their entertainment experience with a wide selection of movies, TV shows, and music.  British Airways takes pride in its focus on British fare, offering a taste of home on board with high-quality meals and beverages.

Finnair

Features spacious seats with adjustable headrests and leg rests, ensuring a comfortable journey. Passengers receive noise-canceling headphones and amenity kits and can enjoy an entertainment system with a wide variety of content. Finnair offers a focus on Nordic cuisine, showcasing fresh and seasonal ingredients from the region.

All Nippon Airways (ANA)

Provides comfortable seats with adjustable headrests and leg rests, designed for maximum comfort on long-haul flights. Passengers appreciate the airline's focus on Japanese hospitality, evident in the exceptional service standards and attention to detail. ANA offers a delectable in-flight dining experience featuring fresh, seasonal Japanese ingredients, alongside an extensive entertainment library with a wide selection of movies, TV shows, and music.

Is Premium Economy Worth It? Or You Paying More for Less?

The question of whether a premium economy is worth it boils down to a cost-benefit analysis. While it offers undeniable advantages over economy class, it still carries a premium price tag.

Let's consider both sides of the coin -

Benefits

Increased Comfort and Productivity - As discussed, the additional space allows for a more comfortable and productive journey. Employees can arrive at their destination less fatigued and ready to work.

Improved Employee Morale - Investing in employee comfort demonstrates a company's commitment to well-being. This can boost morale and loyalty.

Strategic Cost Savings - Compared to business class, premium economy offers significant cost savings. Companies can optimize travel budgets while still prioritizing employee well-being on long-haul flights.

Drawbacks

Higher Cost - The premium economy is more expensive than economy class. Companies need to weigh the additional costs against the perceived benefits.

Not a Business Class Replacement - While offering improved comfort over the economy, the premium economy doesn't replicate the luxury experience of business class. For long journeys where maximum rest is crucial, business class remains the preferred option.

Affecting Factors

Flight Duration - For short-haul flights, the comfort benefits of a premium economy might not justify the extra cost. However, on long-haul journeys, the increased legroom and amenities become more valuable.

Travel Frequency - If employees travel frequently, the cumulative cost savings of premium economy can be significant compared to business class.

Employee Preferences - Consider employee feedback and preferences. Some might prioritize affordability, while others may value increased comfort on long journeys.

A possible approach

Implement a travel policy that utilizes premium economy for flights exceeding a certain duration (e.g., 8 hours).

Allow employees to upgrade to business class using reward points or by covering the difference themselves for priority trips.

When to Spring for Premium Economy

Here are some situations where premium economy shines for corporate travelers:

Long-haul flights where maximizing comfort is important - The extra legroom and improved amenities make a significant difference on long journeys.

Red-eye flights - Increased comfort can help employees arrive at their destination more rested and ready to tackle the day.

Routes with limited business class availability - If business class seats are unavailable, premium economy offers the next best option for comfort.

Travel for high-performing employees or critical projects - Investing in a premium economy demonstrates appreciation and can contribute to success.

By carefully considering the factors discussed above, companies can leverage premium economy airfares to optimize travel budgets while prioritizing employee comfort and well-being. This win-win approach can lead to a more productive and satisfied workforce.

Additional Considerations

While these airlines are generally well-regarded for their premium economy offerings, it's important to note that there can be variations within each airline depending on the specific aircraft and route. Some airlines might offer a slightly smaller seat pitch or entertainment screen on certain routes compared to others. Researching the specific flight you're considering can help ensure you're getting the best value for your corporate travel needs.

For corporate travel managers, utilizing online resources and aggregators that compare premium economy offerings across different airlines can be a valuable tool. This allows for a side-by-side comparison of factors like seat pitch, amenities, and pricing, facilitating informed decision-making when it comes to booking premium economy flights.

Way Ahead

Premium economy airfare presents a compelling option for corporate travel. It offers a significant step up in comfort and amenities compared to standard economy class, without the hefty price tag of business class. By carefully evaluating factors like flight duration, travel frequency, and employee preferences, companies can leverage premium economy to optimize travel budgets while prioritizing employee well-being. Ultimately, a well-crafted travel policy that utilizes premium economy strategically can lead to a more productive and satisfied workforce.

Stay tuned to WegoPro for the latest corporate travel and expense management news and updates!